My Websites
Official Beatles sites
Other Websites
- Archer Valerie Beatles pages
- Beat Gear Cavern
- BeatleLinks
- Beatles History
- Beatles International
- Beatles Pics
- Beatles Wiki
- BeatleSource
- BeatlesTube
- Bill Harry's Mersey Beat
- Bootlegzone
- Demonoid
- Fab Guitars
- Fab News
- Hunger City
- MopTops Guide to the Beatles
- Reunion sessions
- Solo Beatles Photos Forum
- Steve at Examiner.com
- The Beatles Interviews Database
- The Beatles on DVD
- What Goes On?
- Yellow Sub (France)
Featured post
The Daily Beatle
This is a website about all things Beatle. There will be news if we find them attractive, there will also be articles and features about sol...
Followers
Total Pageviews
Archives
Find Us On Facebook
Blogs
-
Listen to What the Man Said - Listen to What the Man Said Written by Timothy Swallow Gold Magazine 1978 Paul McCartney's song "The Mull of Kintyre," recorded and released in D...
-
McCartney & Wings – One Hand Clapping – It’s Official + Pack Shots - Six days after the news mistakenly slipped out, Paul McCartney has officially announced the release of audio from the 1974 live studio performance called O...
-
JOHN LENNON's GUITAR UP FOR AUCTION AFTER DISCOVERY IN ATTIC AFTER 50 YEARS - Julien’s Auctions announced Tuesday, April 23 that Lennon’s Framus 12-string Hootenanny acoustic guit...
-
LIBB P768: 22 April 2024 - Show 1461 Panel: Graeme Dickenson, Gavin Myers, Jo MacCarthy *LIBB Show 1461 WynFM Podcast P768* Download Or Stream LIBB Show 1461 WynFM Podcast P768 ...
-
Feel your own pain – John’s ‘Plastic Ono Band’ demos - When a deluxe edition of John’s classic John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band album was first seriously mooted back in 2020, I was curious to see how deep they coul...
-
Restored Let It Be film coming to Disney+ 05-08-24 - The Beatles’ 1970 film Let It Be is coming to Disney+ on 8 May 2024. The film, directed by Michael Lindsay-Hogg in January 1969, has been commercially un...
-
Having a Large Time! - I’m still working on the manuscript, but I just got the proof for the cover for my upcoming book about Southern music, and I’m very pleased with how it tur...
-
Harry Benson : « Paul » livre l'intimité de McCartney - C’est en 1964 que Harry Benson commence à photographier le jeune Paul McCartney, année charnière pour les Beatles qui déferlent sur l’Amérique, sillonnen...
-
-
ED治療の際はシルデナフィルの使い方を正しくマスターしよう! - シルデナフィルはED治療によく使用されていますが、使い方を間違えると命に関わることもありますので注意が必要です。一番良い方法は、医師や薬剤師など専門家に相談し、指示を守って服用することですが、ここでは一般的に言われているシルデナフィルの正しい使い方についてご紹介します。 市販されているシルデナフィルには25...
-
William Leslie Anthony (Les Anthony): 30 April 1933 - 21 May 2020. - Les Anthony, John's driver from 1965-1971, has died. The story goes that John was having problems finding a suitable chauffeur, and so Brian Epstein, upo...
-
The Decca Tapes - First Time In Stereo (By Lord Reith) - BITRATE: FLAC TRACK LISTING: Money The Sheikh Of Araby Memphis, Tennessee Three Cool Cats Sure To Fall September In The Rain Take Good Care Of My Baby Till...
-
The Final Beatles' Recording Session - On April 01 1970, final work was done on three of the tunes for the upcoming "Let It Be" (formerly known as "Get Back") project. The session was held in St...
-
There are seven levels. - [image: giphy (4)]
-
-
Bitcoin and Other Donations - Hello fellow Beatle-people! I have not been idle but been working on many things including the promised book for Comprehensive Beatles. I hope to have new...
-
-
-
-
Beatles Rarity of the Week – “Act Naturally” (Ringo Starr duet with Cilla Black, 1971) - Welcome to the Beatles Rarity of the Week. On August 1st, 2015 long-time Beatles-friend and fellow Liverpudlian Cilla Black (real name Priscilla Maria Vero...
-
-
-
Translate
Popular Posts
-
"Pure McCartney" is a new 2CD or deluxe 4CD compilation of previously released songs. So the news are out...er somewhat. I gue...
-
The Beatles' "Long Tall Sally" EP, featuring a photo of The Beatles in Sweden. Ok, so we brougth you a survey of the most ...
-
George Harrison Video Collection By Mike Carrera A fan recently asked which was the best Harrison “promo clip compilation” and my resp...
-
From the photo session: The Beatles with Adam, the son of photographer Michael Cooper. If you're looking for news about the upcoming...
-
The Sunday Times: Anniversary re-release of "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club band" due. According to The Sunday Times, a ...
-
The Beatles in Madrid (the photos, that is) Okay, we fell for it, hook, line and sinker. It was after all, a good story with a beautiful...
-
LET IT BE In a new interview with Cinematographer Tony Richmond, who worked on the "Let It Be" film under director Michael Lin...
-
Get your tickets for a special recording session with Sir Paul at BBC Maida Vale Studios! The radio series Mastertapes returns to BBC R...
-
Record store in Amsterdam From Monday to Friday last week, I've been in Amsterdam in Holland. And that's where I was when the ne...
Video Of Day
Our Shop
Statistics
About Us
This website is all about The Beatles and the individual members of The Beatles. It is kept by Roger Stormo, who has been associated with the Norwegian Beatles fan club, "Norwegian Wood", since 1980. Feel free to quote from the site, but please give me credit and a link back to the original item. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This is not a news site per se, but if we hear about something that has yet to be reported by other Beatles news services, we tend to write about it. Apart from that, we will write stuff about the Beatles on an irregular basis at the whim of the author. A lot of our readers arrive at specific articles from internet searches or references to this site from forums and other Beatles sites. If you did, we encourage you to click here to access the main page, and also to indulge in our archives - you may find other posts that are interesting. You may also subscribe to news from the site and have each new issue delivered to your rss feed reader.
This is not a begging letter... but feel free to support me by donating money! It'll keep me in business... Or just buy a t-shirt! Or take a look at my Amazon wish list...If you have Beatles related product to push, feel free to send us a copy, the address is:
Roger Stormo
Baglergata 21B
NO-2004 Lillestrøm
NORWAY
email: roger.stormo@gmail.com
We can't promise that your product will be featured on the site, but it stands a better chance than the ones we don't get...
Mobile site
Move over, Ms L!
Monday 22 March 2010
Book review: Fact and Fiction 1960-1962
Last year, the book was finally published in an English, updated and revised edition. I bought it and started to read it, but I was not able to finish it until now.
The years that are covered in the book is an interesting period, and one that's more important this year, because it's now the fiftieth anniversary of 1960. Krasker was born that year, so his is not a first hand account, his work has been that of a detective, historian and researcher.
There have been several earlier books dealing with these formative years of the early Beatles. Allan Williams, who managed the Beatles at this time, gave his account of these years back in 1975 in his "The Man Who Gave The Beatles Away" book, early Beatles historian, the late Gareth Pawlowski collected a lot of photos, record sleeves and information in his How They Became the Beatles from 1989, and there's been inside information (and myths) in books by people like Pete Best, Cynthia Lennon and Bill Harry. But the current standard work about this period is a book by Swedish author Hans Olof Gottfridsson, a tome with the title From Cavern to Star-Club, published in 1997.
In the course of investigating the era, Krasker seems to have become annoyed by a number of mistakes, misinterpretations and erroneous assumptions and speculations in the "From Cavern to Star-Club" book. A great deal of this new book is dedicated to expose these errors and explain how and why Gottfridsson was mistaken.
Krasker is using a method which relies heavy on documentation and rationing. In his eyes, no fact can be established unless it is certified by a document. Under each "fact" or "myth", Krasker explains the circumstances, where each "fact" has been previously published, what evidence there is and discusses what the possibilities are.
Sometimes, he has no conclusion because there's no theory which can be established as a fact - there's just no documentation. But at least he gives us all the previous information, tells us who wrote what and what he suspects is the truth.
Every time Krasker quotes from earlier publications, a numbered footnote corresponds to a list after each chapter where the original source is named. You can move to and fro as you're reading, or just explore the list after finishing each chapter, which is what I did.
Like I said, these years are important in the history of the Beatles. The years they spent as The Beatles in Hamburg and Liverpool formed their characters, playing style, competitiveness and explains the dynamics within the band. And a number of very important and interesting subjects are from this time period. What caused Stuart Sutcliffe's death? Why was Pete Best sacked as their drummer? Why was it Ringo that was hired? Under what circumstances did the Tony Sheridan Polydor recordings come about? How and why were these recordings "doctored" for the American market? Did Raymond Jones really exist? What are the Star-Club recordings, how and when were they recorded, how many sets were documented on the tape (or was it tapes), and what's the most likely running order of those songs?
Since the publication of the French edition of the book, several new facts have appeared, a few myths have been exposed and some hitherto unheard songs from the Star-Club recordings have been unearthed. Some times the original text has been kept with these new findings discussed at the end of the chapter, and some times the entire chapter has been rewritten in the light of the new discoveries.
So why was Pete Best sacked? This book will tell you about the many theories; George Martin was dissatisfied with Best's skills as a drummer, he was too popular with the girls, he was a loner and didn't fit in with the rest of the group, he wouldn't or couldn't conform to "the Beatles haircut", Epstein didn't want Pete's mother Mona Best to involve herself with the group's bookings, Paul didn't want to compete with Pete's looks, etc etc. Even though this is the kind of fact that can't be established with conclusive documentation, Krasker - a drummer in his own right - gives us a plausible conclusion. After a number of drummerless periods as the Quarrymen, the Moondogs and Silver Beatles, they finally found a drummer that wanted to stay, and had a brand new kit. Even though he wasn't good enough, they stuck with him, hoping he would improve and evolve along with themselves. And he did, but only to a certain extent. After he discovered his "atom beat", with heavy use of the bass drum, he was stuck in a rut. His drumming style was a problem in the studio, even as early as at the Polydor recordings, and he did nothing to accomodate the producer's needs, neither at Polydor, nor at Decca or EMI. He only had one style of drumming, which he could perform slow, medium or fast. Krasker even reckons that John Lennon's signature way of performing his rythm guitar parts was developed to compensate for Best's lack of time keeping. Besides that, he didn't have the personality. Krasker has spent time with Best and even though Best was an amiable fellow and good company, he was a quiet kind and probably no match for the wit and humour of the rest of the lads.
As for the cause of Stuart Sutcliffe's death, the movie "BackBeat" from 1994 has left an imprint in many people's minds that a blow to the head from a fight in Liverpool may have ultimately lead to Sutcliffe's headaches and later death in Hamburg in 1962. Krasker sticks to the facts: the post-mortem declares that Sutcliffe's deat was caused by "cerebral paralysis due to bleeding into the right ventricle of the brain". A possible brain tumour, as reported by Philip Norman in his book "Shout!", based on some x-ray plates showing a small shadow in Start's brain is dismissed, because it's not reported in the post-mortem. Surely they would have found it if it was ever there. A possible blow to the head from a fight, either with teddy boys in Liverpool, or as the late Albert Goldman wrote in his scandalous "The Lives of John Lennon", with Stuart's mate Lennon, causing an indentation in the skull is not reported in the post-mortem, and if there ever was one, they would have reported it. The chapter also speculates that Stuart's brain may have suffered from the abuse of drugs (preludin), alcohol and cigarettes, but again reaches no conclusion.
This book does not replace Gottfridsson's "From Cavern to Star-Club", but is an important addendum and a must-read if you're interested in the rich mythology surrounding the early history of the Beatles. It will put you straight about the facts surrounding the Polydor recording sessions, and correct earlier mistakes in Gottfridsson's book. The book is thoroughly illustrated with photos, record sleeves and important documents of the era. Ending the 442 pages of this book are four handy references: a bibliography, a name index, a song index and an index of the contents of the book.
Krasker is also co-author of the French discography book of the Beatles, "La France et Les Beatles", from 2005.
Preview the book.
Order the book.
No comments:
Post a Comment